{
  "n_religious": 24,
  "n_secular": 16,
  "n_traditions": 11,
  "traditions": [
    "Apocryphes/2e Temple",
    "Bouddhisme",
    "Christianisme",
    "Confucianisme",
    "Hindouisme",
    "Islam",
    "Mormonisme",
    "Polythéisme grec",
    "Polythéisme nordique",
    "Taoïsme",
    "Égypte ancienne"
  ],
  "doubt_split": {
    "form": {
      "mean_religious": 4.591,
      "mean_secular": 6.539,
      "cohens_d": -0.495,
      "p_perm": 0.132
    },
    "epistemic": {
      "mean_religious": 1.275,
      "mean_secular": 1.91,
      "cohens_d": -0.923,
      "p_perm": 0.0058
    },
    "combined": {
      "mean_religious": 1.496,
      "mean_secular": 2.452,
      "cohens_d": -0.941,
      "p_perm": 0.0048
    },
    "interpretation": "Si le gap religieux<séculier vient surtout de 'form' (questions, why, ?), le marqueur capte la forme dialogique socratique autant que le doute épistémique. Si 'epistemic' (perhaps, doubt, uncertain) porte l'effet, le finding est plus solide."
  },
  "fingerprint": {
    "Apocryphes/2e Temple": {
      "appeals_to_authority": 1.749,
      "prescriptive_imperatives": 2.152,
      "reward_punishment": 5.409,
      "ingroup_outgroup": 1.193,
      "doubt_inquiry": 0.659,
      "embodiment_practice": 0.689,
      "exclusive_truth": 0.034,
      "miracles_signs": 1.018,
      "supernatural_beings": 1.922,
      "submission_obedience": 0.345,
      "_n_texts": 2
    },
    "Bouddhisme": {
      "appeals_to_authority": 0.194,
      "prescriptive_imperatives": 2.35,
      "reward_punishment": 1.98,
      "ingroup_outgroup": 0.3,
      "doubt_inquiry": 2.686,
      "embodiment_practice": 7.162,
      "exclusive_truth": 0.0,
      "miracles_signs": 0.306,
      "supernatural_beings": 0.071,
      "submission_obedience": 0.323,
      "_n_texts": 2
    },
    "Christianisme": {
      "appeals_to_authority": 3.079,
      "prescriptive_imperatives": 2.579,
      "reward_punishment": 2.891,
      "ingroup_outgroup": 0.437,
      "doubt_inquiry": 1.664,
      "embodiment_practice": 2.184,
      "exclusive_truth": 0.062,
      "miracles_signs": 0.546,
      "supernatural_beings": 0.937,
      "submission_obedience": 0.565,
      "_n_texts": 4
    },
    "Confucianisme": {
      "appeals_to_authority": 15.317,
      "prescriptive_imperatives": 1.516,
      "reward_punishment": 2.952,
      "ingroup_outgroup": 0.0,
      "doubt_inquiry": 2.148,
      "embodiment_practice": 0.875,
      "exclusive_truth": 0.0,
      "miracles_signs": 0.028,
      "supernatural_beings": 0.047,
      "submission_obedience": 0.306,
      "_n_texts": 2
    },
    "Hindouisme": {
      "appeals_to_authority": 0.935,
      "prescriptive_imperatives": 1.106,
      "reward_punishment": 2.705,
      "ingroup_outgroup": 0.059,
      "doubt_inquiry": 1.086,
      "embodiment_practice": 7.981,
      "exclusive_truth": 0.073,
      "miracles_signs": 0.375,
      "supernatural_beings": 0.293,
      "submission_obedience": 1.045,
      "_n_texts": 3
    },
    "Islam": {
      "appeals_to_authority": 2.239,
      "prescriptive_imperatives": 1.676,
      "reward_punishment": 2.972,
      "ingroup_outgroup": 1.925,
      "doubt_inquiry": 1.943,
      "embodiment_practice": 0.983,
      "exclusive_truth": 0.162,
      "miracles_signs": 1.354,
      "supernatural_beings": 0.684,
      "submission_obedience": 1.033,
      "_n_texts": 2
    },
    "Mormonisme": {
      "appeals_to_authority": 5.588,
      "prescriptive_imperatives": 2.127,
      "reward_punishment": 2.917,
      "ingroup_outgroup": 0.796,
      "doubt_inquiry": 1.004,
      "embodiment_practice": 0.582,
      "exclusive_truth": 0.153,
      "miracles_signs": 2.744,
      "supernatural_beings": 2.893,
      "submission_obedience": 0.363,
      "_n_texts": 2
    },
    "Polythéisme grec": {
      "appeals_to_authority": 0.187,
      "prescriptive_imperatives": 0.914,
      "reward_punishment": 2.522,
      "ingroup_outgroup": 0.022,
      "doubt_inquiry": 0.87,
      "embodiment_practice": 0.782,
      "exclusive_truth": 0.022,
      "miracles_signs": 0.264,
      "supernatural_beings": 0.0,
      "submission_obedience": 0.088,
      "_n_texts": 1
    },
    "Polythéisme nordique": {
      "appeals_to_authority": 0.249,
      "prescriptive_imperatives": 0.527,
      "reward_punishment": 2.407,
      "ingroup_outgroup": 0.115,
      "doubt_inquiry": 1.283,
      "embodiment_practice": 0.795,
      "exclusive_truth": 0.017,
      "miracles_signs": 0.415,
      "supernatural_beings": 0.091,
      "submission_obedience": 0.084,
      "_n_texts": 2
    },
    "Taoïsme": {
      "appeals_to_authority": 0.531,
      "prescriptive_imperatives": 2.427,
      "reward_punishment": 2.628,
      "ingroup_outgroup": 0.013,
      "doubt_inquiry": 1.863,
      "embodiment_practice": 2.512,
      "exclusive_truth": 0.004,
      "miracles_signs": 0.111,
      "supernatural_beings": 0.027,
      "submission_obedience": 0.2,
      "_n_texts": 2
    },
    "Égypte ancienne": {
      "appeals_to_authority": 1.263,
      "prescriptive_imperatives": 1.076,
      "reward_punishment": 1.824,
      "ingroup_outgroup": 0.031,
      "doubt_inquiry": 0.975,
      "embodiment_practice": 1.329,
      "exclusive_truth": 0.037,
      "miracles_signs": 0.173,
      "supernatural_beings": 0.157,
      "submission_obedience": 0.236,
      "_n_texts": 2
    }
  },
  "tradition_distinctive": {
    "Apocryphes/2e Temple": [
      {
        "marker": "reward_punishment",
        "z": 1.89
      },
      {
        "marker": "supernatural_beings",
        "z": 1.16
      },
      {
        "marker": "ingroup_outgroup",
        "z": 1.07
      }
    ],
    "Bouddhisme": [
      {
        "marker": "embodiment_practice",
        "z": 1.43
      },
      {
        "marker": "doubt_inquiry",
        "z": 1.21
      },
      {
        "marker": "prescriptive_imperatives",
        "z": 0.58
      }
    ],
    "Christianisme": [
      {
        "marker": "prescriptive_imperatives",
        "z": 0.8
      },
      {
        "marker": "supernatural_beings",
        "z": 0.24
      },
      {
        "marker": "submission_obedience",
        "z": 0.21
      }
    ],
    "Confucianisme": [
      {
        "marker": "appeals_to_authority",
        "z": 2.05
      },
      {
        "marker": "doubt_inquiry",
        "z": 0.66
      },
      {
        "marker": "reward_punishment",
        "z": 0.08
      }
    ],
    "Hindouisme": [
      {
        "marker": "embodiment_practice",
        "z": 1.69
      },
      {
        "marker": "submission_obedience",
        "z": 1.28
      },
      {
        "marker": "exclusive_truth",
        "z": 0.29
      }
    ],
    "Islam": [
      {
        "marker": "ingroup_outgroup",
        "z": 2.12
      },
      {
        "marker": "exclusive_truth",
        "z": 1.65
      },
      {
        "marker": "submission_obedience",
        "z": 1.26
      }
    ],
    "Mormonisme": [
      {
        "marker": "miracles_signs",
        "z": 2.27
      },
      {
        "marker": "supernatural_beings",
        "z": 2.07
      },
      {
        "marker": "exclusive_truth",
        "z": 1.51
      }
    ],
    "Polythéisme grec": [
      {
        "marker": "reward_punishment",
        "z": -0.24
      },
      {
        "marker": "miracles_signs",
        "z": -0.43
      },
      {
        "marker": "appeals_to_authority",
        "z": -0.45
      }
    ],
    "Polythéisme nordique": [
      {
        "marker": "doubt_inquiry",
        "z": -0.22
      },
      {
        "marker": "miracles_signs",
        "z": -0.27
      },
      {
        "marker": "reward_punishment",
        "z": -0.33
      }
    ],
    "Taoïsme": [
      {
        "marker": "prescriptive_imperatives",
        "z": 0.65
      },
      {
        "marker": "doubt_inquiry",
        "z": 0.37
      },
      {
        "marker": "embodiment_practice",
        "z": -0.04
      }
    ],
    "Égypte ancienne": [
      {
        "marker": "appeals_to_authority",
        "z": -0.27
      },
      {
        "marker": "exclusive_truth",
        "z": -0.27
      },
      {
        "marker": "embodiment_practice",
        "z": -0.41
      }
    ]
  },
  "idiom_classification": [
    {
      "marker": "reward_punishment",
      "d_full": 1.524,
      "top_tradition": "Apocryphes/2e Temple",
      "top_rate": 5.409,
      "breadth_traditions": 11,
      "n_traditions": 11,
      "concentration_ratio": 2.03,
      "loo_drop_tradition": "Christianisme",
      "loo_min_d": 1.424,
      "loo_d_drop": 0.099,
      "verdict": "universel"
    },
    {
      "marker": "supernatural_beings",
      "d_full": 0.867,
      "top_tradition": "Mormonisme",
      "top_rate": 2.893,
      "breadth_traditions": 4,
      "n_traditions": 11,
      "concentration_ratio": 23.33,
      "loo_drop_tradition": "Christianisme",
      "loo_min_d": 0.745,
      "loo_d_drop": 0.123,
      "verdict": "semi-idiome (Mormonisme)"
    },
    {
      "marker": "ingroup_outgroup",
      "d_full": 0.847,
      "top_tradition": "Islam",
      "top_rate": 1.925,
      "breadth_traditions": 4,
      "n_traditions": 11,
      "concentration_ratio": 22.13,
      "loo_drop_tradition": "Apocryphes/2e Temple",
      "loo_min_d": 0.73,
      "loo_d_drop": 0.117,
      "verdict": "semi-idiome (Islam)"
    },
    {
      "marker": "exclusive_truth",
      "d_full": 0.671,
      "top_tradition": "Islam",
      "top_rate": 0.162,
      "breadth_traditions": 6,
      "n_traditions": 11,
      "concentration_ratio": 5.79,
      "loo_drop_tradition": "Mormonisme",
      "loo_min_d": 0.536,
      "loo_d_drop": 0.135,
      "verdict": "universel"
    },
    {
      "marker": "miracles_signs",
      "d_full": 0.637,
      "top_tradition": "Mormonisme",
      "top_rate": 2.744,
      "breadth_traditions": 3,
      "n_traditions": 11,
      "concentration_ratio": 8.06,
      "loo_drop_tradition": "Islam",
      "loo_min_d": 0.535,
      "loo_d_drop": 0.102,
      "verdict": "idiome (Mormonisme)"
    },
    {
      "marker": "submission_obedience",
      "d_full": 0.578,
      "top_tradition": "Hindouisme",
      "top_rate": 1.045,
      "breadth_traditions": 8,
      "n_traditions": 11,
      "concentration_ratio": 3.32,
      "loo_drop_tradition": "Hindouisme",
      "loo_min_d": 0.394,
      "loo_d_drop": 0.184,
      "verdict": "universel"
    },
    {
      "marker": "appeals_to_authority",
      "d_full": 0.567,
      "top_tradition": "Confucianisme",
      "top_rate": 15.317,
      "breadth_traditions": 3,
      "n_traditions": 11,
      "concentration_ratio": 13.94,
      "loo_drop_tradition": "Mormonisme",
      "loo_min_d": 0.5,
      "loo_d_drop": 0.067,
      "verdict": "idiome (Confucianisme)"
    },
    {
      "marker": "prescriptive_imperatives",
      "d_full": 0.475,
      "top_tradition": "Christianisme",
      "top_rate": 2.579,
      "breadth_traditions": 11,
      "n_traditions": 11,
      "concentration_ratio": 1.62,
      "loo_drop_tradition": "Christianisme",
      "loo_min_d": 0.308,
      "loo_d_drop": 0.167,
      "verdict": "universel"
    },
    {
      "marker": "embodiment_practice",
      "d_full": 0.077,
      "top_tradition": "Hindouisme",
      "top_rate": 7.981,
      "breadth_traditions": 4,
      "n_traditions": 11,
      "concentration_ratio": 8.59,
      "loo_drop_tradition": "Hindouisme",
      "loo_min_d": -0.316,
      "loo_d_drop": 0.393,
      "verdict": "non discriminant"
    },
    {
      "marker": "doubt_inquiry",
      "d_full": -0.941,
      "top_tradition": "Bouddhisme",
      "top_rate": 2.686,
      "breadth_traditions": 11,
      "n_traditions": 11,
      "concentration_ratio": 2.27,
      "loo_drop_tradition": "Bouddhisme",
      "loo_min_d": -1.235,
      "loo_d_drop": 0.294,
      "verdict": "universel"
    }
  ],
  "note": "breadth = nb de traditions où le marqueur atteint >=20% du taux de la tradition leader. universel = présent dans >=6 traditions ; idiome = concentré dans <=3 et le leader domine (>=3x la médiane des autres). loo = leave-one-tradition-out.",
  "_provenance": {
    "generated_at": "2026-07-15T07:21:07+00:00",
    "git_sha": "3d4a1fb7-dirty",
    "corpus": {
      "n_texts": 44,
      "sha1": "8da9adb16f18"
    },
    "script": "10_idiom_detector"
  }
}